Danbooru

fixing some song tags (+additional tagging discussion)

Posted under Tags

BUR #14986 has been approved by @evazion.

Show

rename adaposha_(iyowa) -> adipocere_(vocaloid)
rename isei_ni_ikou_ne_(iyowa) -> isei_ni_ikou_ne_(cevio)
rename chikyuu_no_ura_(iyowa) -> chikyuu_no_ura_(cevio)
rename clover_knight_(iyowa) -> clover_knight_(vocaloid)
rename imawanokiwa_(iyowa) -> imawanokiwa_(vocaloid)
rename apricot_(iyowa) -> apricot_(vocaloid)
rename netsu_ijou_(iyowa) -> netsu_ijou_(utau)
rename 1000-nen_ikiteru_(iyowa) -> 1000-nen_ikiteru_(vocaloid)
rename bakushou_(syudou) -> bakushou_(song)
rename aru_sekai_shoushitsu -> aru_sekai_shoushitsu_(vocaloid)
rename shuuen_touhikou -> shuuen_touhikou_(vocaloid)
nuke girl_(adaposha)
nuke girl_(kyu-kurarin)
nuke girl_(apricot)
nuke girl_(hell_mp)
nuke alien_girl_(isei_ni_ikou_ne)
nuke cat_girl_(chikyuu_no_ura)
nuke literature_girl_(clover_knight)
nuke mother_(imawanokiwa)
nuke octopus_man_(bakushou)
nuke cute_girlfriend
nuke inabakumori_(vocaloid)

Some bad tags and wiki mostly done by a single user. For the moment, synthesizer songs use the corresponding engine qualifier. I'm still not convinced that we need a bunch of random unnamed girl tags after topic #22607, as that would apply to at least half of the vocaloid song and it'll just be padding. Another solution is to grouped them under original which also has it's problem, since technically the song already acts as the character's copyright and thus they aren't "original".

That said, the current system is not perfect either and we could really use some update. I do have to say that with the self cover and multiple official version trend raising it might be time that we reconsider the qualifier we use. There're also other unresolved issues like human song tagging inconsistency etc, but all of these involve some drastic changes and shouldn't be done without and proper discussion. (but as we all know music is the form of copyright that people care the least, topic #21922 and topic #22607 both failed)

Updated

BUR #14987 has been approved by @evazion.

rename shelter_(music_video) -> shelter_(song)
rename kick_back_(music_video) -> kick_back_(song)
rename ghost_(music_video) -> ghost_(song)
rename chu_tayousei_(music_video) -> chu_tayousei_(song)
rename inu-hime_(music_video) -> inu-hime_(song)

Currently human songs have many different types of qualifier: *_(song), *_(artist_name), *_(music_video), *_(the parent copyright they belong to such as love live) or just no qualifier at all. But *_(music_video) is the least convincing. There's also the long lasting general tag vs copyright tag issue.

Updated

support because the above tags apply to both references to the artist's music video and the associated anime opening if applicable

chu tayousei might not need a qualifier at all

debatable as to whether these should all be copyright tags

1