BUR #18699 has been rejected.
create implication sleeves_past_elbows -> long_sleeves
Just like how capri_pants are pants, and over-kneehighs are thighhighs, sleeves_past_elbows are long_sleeves.
Posted under Tags
BUR #18699 has been rejected.
create implication sleeves_past_elbows -> long_sleeves
Just like how capri_pants are pants, and over-kneehighs are thighhighs, sleeves_past_elbows are long_sleeves.
In which case sleeves past wrists wouldn't be long sleeves as well? Shouldn't it be implicated as well?
Lyren said:
In which case sleeves past wrists wouldn't be long sleeves as well? Shouldn't it be implicated as well?
See topic #20529.
No; then I'd have to search long_sleeves -sleeves_past_elbows just to get some properly long sleeves. I'd rather have the tags for "just past elbow" and "to the wrist" be totally separate. I don't think if I even consider these long sleeves when talking about them verbally, unless it's a shirt with sleeves rolled up to the elbow.
Though actual long sleeves are overwhelmingly more common, so it's not like they'd be difficult to find in the search. Still annoying to filter out, though.
LQ said:
No; then I'd have to search long_sleeves -sleeves_past_elbows just to get some properly long sleeves. I'd rather have the tags for "just past elbow" and "to the wrist" be totally separate. I don't think if I even consider these long sleeves when talking about them verbally, unless it's a shirt with sleeves rolled up to the elbow.
Though actual long sleeves are overwhelmingly more common, so it's not like they'd be difficult to find in the search. Still annoying to filter out, though.
This might be an argument if it would impact searches, but as you mention, what we currently define as long sleeves is overwhelmingly more common. In fact, they are so overwhelmingly more common that for every sleeves_past_elbows post, there are over two hundred long_sleeves posts. Forget being annoying to filter out; there's a decent chance you don't see even one of them until you're ten pages into a search.
I have always tagged long sleeves as long as it goes past the elbows, if it was me I'd even alias sleeves past elbows to that tag as it feels needlessly granular to have a tag for that.
Seeing this BUR pop up again reminds me of my thought that a medium sleeves tag might do some good. Would solve a lot of this "are they short sleeves or long sleeves?" tagging problems by giving an in-between third option.
In practice, I think that tag would require a lot of gardening and upkeep in order to maintain it. But even so, I still like the concept in theory.
The bulk update request #18699 (forum #249119) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.