Tag Implication: suika_bar -> watermelon

Implicating suika_bar -> watermelon.

Reason: It's a watermelon -shaped and -flavored popsicle.

I would be against this, because people searching for watermelon are looking for the actual melon. We don't implicate onigiri to rice, or taiyaki to fish.

Yeah, it may be watermelon-like, but it isn't actually a watermelon.

Well, to be honest, I was kinda iffy on this myself. I'd been kinda puzzled after a certain pic, where I replaced watermelon with suika_bar.

Glad the opinions are same.

I agree it shouldn't implicate watermelon, but it could implicate popsicle or maybe ice_cream.

eidolon said: I agree it shouldn't implicate watermelon, but it could implicate popsicle or maybe ice_cream.

Popsicle seems fair. Implicated.

jxh2154 said:
Popsicle seems fair. Implicated.

After all it is a Popsicle.

From the looks of things we might want to define ice_cream/popsicle, a quick browse through ice cream popped up way too many popsicles tagged ice_cream (more than zero.)

fwiw "popsicle" is trademarked, and only genericized in the US (and Canada?). The more general term would be "ice pop" or something like that. But whatever, hardly matters.