Danbooru

About Sakurada Shiro lite costume tags

Posted under Tags

BUR #29029 has been rejected.

rename sakurada_shiro_(original_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(original)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(summer_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(summer)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(winter_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(winter)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(royal_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(royal)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(autumn_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(autumn)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(spring_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(spring)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(idol_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(idol)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(healer_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(healer)_(hy_plus)

Although the character tags for costumes are categorized in great detail, I am not aware of the specific differences between those that include "lite" and those that do not (these differences are not elaborated on in the wiki either). Therefore, I believe this could cause confusion for future uploaders.
Moreover, I think that during a typical search, users are unlikely to pay much attention to whether the costume is a "lite" version.
Finally, I would like to invite the relevant user to address these questions:
@Nmless

WaterMiner said:

BUR #29029 has been rejected.

rename sakurada_shiro_(original_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(original)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(summer_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(summer)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(winter_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(winter)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(royal_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(royal)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(autumn_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(autumn)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(spring_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(spring)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(idol_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(idol)_(hy_plus)
rename sakurada_shiro_(healer_lite)_(hy_plus) -> sakurada_shiro_(healer)_(hy_plus)

Although the character tags for costumes are categorized in great detail, I am not aware of the specific differences between those that include "lite" and those that do not (these differences are not elaborated on in the wiki either). Therefore, I believe this could cause confusion for future uploaders.
Moreover, I think that during a typical search, users are unlikely to pay much attention to whether the costume is a "lite" version.
Finally, I would like to invite the relevant user to address these questions:
@Nmless

@WaterMiner
The lite version has fewer costumes than the normal version, and the missing costumes are very obvious, so I made a distinction between them.
For example, #7646268 and #7646310, as well as other lite versions of costumes, are costumes with some costumes removed. On Sakurada Shiro's official website, each of her costumes is also displayed in two versions, and hy_plus should also use two versions for commissioning.
If there is no difference between the lite and the original version, I will definitely put the lite version and the original version into one clothing tag when editing tags in the past. But for those who want to search for the original and lite versions, it is necessary to distinguish between lite and original versions (such as me).
If you want to retrieve posts with both the original and lite versions, you can search using both tags. But without the lite version of the outfit tag, others will have to identify the two versions of the outfit on their own.

Updated

Nmless said:

@WaterMiner
The lite version has fewer costumes than the normal version, and the missing costumes are very obvious, so I made a distinction between them.
For example, post #7646268 and post #7646310, as well as other lite versions of costumes, are costumes with some costumes removed. On Sakurada Shiro's official website, each of her costumes is also displayed in two versions, and hy_plus should also use two versions for commissioning.
If there is no difference between the lite and the original version, I will definitely put the lite version and the original version into one clothing tag when editing tags in the past. But for those who want to search for the original and lite versions, it is necessary to distinguish between lite and original versions (such as me).
If you want to retrieve posts with both the original and lite versions, you can search using both tags. But without the lite version of the outfit tag, others will have to identify the two versions of the outfit on their own.

@Nmless
Allright,I understand,Thank you.
But I still have some questions at post #7647147 and post #7647158
The only difference between them seems to be whether they are holding_staff or not.🤔
At last,I think we can add more details to the wiki,such as

Describe the character's appearance. Be descriptive enough that someone unfamiliar with the character will be able to recognize and tag that character.

Heartcatcher said:

...Are we supposed to be tagging alternate costumes like this for original characters? That definitely seems like a slippery slope.

@Heartcatcher
So this is just my personal behavior, I added all the clothing tags for sakurada shiro. I also looked at the clothing tags of other characters and knew that almost every outfit tag for other characters only has one. So I have my motivation for doing this, and I will explain it to you next.
Example: suzuran_(spring_praise)_(arknights).
Appearance: All the posts for suzuran's spring praise outfits have almost the same characteristics, and there are no changes in clothing or accessories.
Character design: There is no other version of suzuran's outfit, it is unique, and this one clothing tag can meet the needs of tagging.
And now, back to the character sakurada shiro, I will give an example to illustrate the obvious differences between different versions of an outfit.
sakurada_shiro_(autumn)_(hy_plus): Brown long-sleeved sailor collar jacket, split in the middle, revealing a white dress worn under the jacket.
sakurada_shiro_(autumn_lite)_(hy_plus): White strapless off-shoulder dress - (off-shoulder).
The appearance of both:
1. Autumn wears a brown jacket based on autumn_lite, which covers the theme of the white dress and covers the shoulders and arms.
2. Autumn_lite takes off the jacket based on autumn, resulting in the character now only wearing a white dress, revealing shoulders and arms.
Character design: There are indeed two versions of each costume designed by the artist.
Autumn and its lite version: post #7646845 and post #7646840.
So, I used two tags to mark them separately, so that the different situations of this costume can be clearly distinguished.
Finally, each of sakurada shiro's costumes look different, and the original character designs also had lite versions of each costume, so of course the tags had to be differentiated. I was the only one who added and edited the costume tags, and I didn't destroy the work of others. I think the lite version of the costume tags doesn't hinder anyone, and it also makes it easier for people in need to search for different character costumes. These are my reasons.

Updated

WaterMiner said:

@Nmless
Allright,I understand,Thank you.
But I still have some questions at post #7647147 and post #7647158
The only difference between them seems to be whether they are holding_staff or not.🤔
At last,I think we can add more details to the wiki,such as

@WaterMiner
The most obvious difference in the healer's outfit is the very loose hooded cape, which is so loose that it almost exposes the shoulders, but it still covers the shoulders (I just realized this now, because the visual effect from the front makes the cape that covers the shoulders look like a large bow on the chest...).
Then there is the black ribbonbowtie on the chest.
Other than that, there is basically no difference.
The staff does not seem to be a criterion for distinction, because as long as the artist wants to add it, it can still be seen in the lite version.
Finally, you are right... I had planned to continue to improve the wiki, but I stopped. I must find time to improve the wiki later.

1