Official art redraw

I just saw post #9116055 and it made me wonder if there should be an official art redraw tag.
To be honest even if this tag was made only the mentioned post, post #6657243 and post #7863396 and it's children comes to mind, I just think it would be an interesting tag to have.

I like that suggestion!

I know that a lot of them are in redrawn at the moment if you wanted to make a favgroup for it I'd support a tag for it.

Not all but most of vocaloid boxart pose should probably count.

BUR #39869 has been rejected.

mass update favgroup:42623 -> official_art_redraw

Here are some examples.

Usually screenshot redraw is used for these, even though that tag is supposed to be used for real life photos rather than derivatives.

i would assume that tag isn't primarily meant for real life photos as you generally do not screenshot real life

zetsubousensei said:

I know that a lot of them are in redrawn at the moment if you wanted to make a favgroup for it I'd support a tag for it.

that tag (redrawn that is) really feels like it's trying to do two different things. I feel that should only be for self-redraws (much like how revision is pretty much always for self revisions) - i.e. the wiki should be reworded to just enforce that imo.

because wouldn't anything in redrawn that isn't a self-redraw just simply fall under derivative work?

c_spl said:

that tag (redrawn that is) really feels like it's trying to do two different things. I feel that should only be for self-redraws (much like how revision is pretty much always for self revisions) - i.e. the wiki should be reworded to just enforce that imo.

because wouldn't anything in redrawn that isn't a self-redraw just simply fall under derivative work?

Yeah, we should probably split redrawn into self-redrawn or something, and derivative work. Though redrawn is different in the sense that derivative work also has shameless traces, not just redraws on purpose/as a challenge.

nonamethanks said:

Yeah, we should probably split redrawn into self-redrawn or something, and derivative work. Though redrawn is different in the sense that derivative work also has shameless traces, not just redraws on purpose/as a challenge.

Then self-redrawn and redraw challenge or something? I can't think of a term that can properly distinguish purposefully drawn redraw versus traced art.

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #39869 (forum #346672) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.