Funny I would think Homerun-chan would be Suzuha, Mami as Moeka is obviously because of boobs, Madoka would make more sense as Kurisu, I have no idea about Kyouko and Sayako though.

MamiMoeka and HomuraKurisu work perfectly. Madoka should've been Mayuri, Sayaka Ruka and Kyouko Suzuha.

But Homura and Suzuha are both time travelers and Homura also had twin braids as well.

Though Homura could be Moeka too since Homura also used to be a glasses girl.

Kyouko is probably the most tsundere and has a similar hair color, so she should be Kurisu.