Someone thinks the chest and thighs are grotesque when we have this and this and this all over the place? Are you shitting me? Not even close. It's not realistic, no, but that's not a pre-requisite.

Stop using the appeal system on flagged posts that have yet to be deleted. It's just a meaningless red border.

With that said, grotesque or not the anatomy is pretty bad here, especially with the one on the right - and the presence of worse things on the website doesn't magically excuse bad posts. Also I'm not the one who flagged this, by the way.

There's nothing that stops using appeal system on flagged posts. This is what people shall do when they see undeserved flag, right?

And it's just this artist's artstyle - it's not something anatomicaly correct but if we want to delete this picture then i will just ask - why every other post from this artist was accepted? If people came to conclusion that this artstyle is acceptable on danbooru then i don't see any reason for flaggin this picture.

And yes, "presence of worse things" means that this kind of picture was accepted on danbooru, so it is a reason to say that a flag is undeserved.

No, the appeal system is meant to be used to appeal a deleted post, not push your opinion about a flagged post at the top of the page. So no, what people should do when they see an undeserved flag is wait for it to be re-approved or appeal it after it's been deleted.

Because most of the artist's pieces are nowhere as bad as this is in terms of proportion and anatomy. The right Youmu's upperbody isn't even lined up with her lower body properly because of the disproportionately sized hips.

Again, the presence of worse things on danbooru doesn't excuse bad posts, it just means those worse things have been wrongly approved and should be flagged, not that a bad post should be considered up-to-standards.

Again, the presence of worse things on danbooru doesn't excuse bad posts, it just means those worse things have been wrongly approved and should be flagged, not that a bad post should be considered up-to-standards.

I wouldn't argue if that was even the flag reason. The flag reason is "Their thighs and boobs are too big," when, no, they're not. The presence of other errors might be the deciding factor if it stays or not, but the currently given reason is useless.

Yeah, that's a fair point. Seems like it's staying, in any case - I still think the anatomy is horribly wonky especially on the right Youmu, but seeing as it was flagged and reapproved, I'm not going to flag it a second time.

To (re)flagger: This post has a +9 rating, so your work is kinda in wain because no matter what it will stay here. Please calm yourself and deal with the fact that community decided that this post will be not banned.

Drewko said:

To (re)flagger: This post has a +9 rating, so your work is kinda in wain because no matter what it will stay here. Please calm yourself and deal with the fact that community decided that this post will be not banned.

I don't know for sure, but I think the number of approvers that consider score on whether to approve an image is miniscule if non-zero.

Is every favorite still +1, or did that get reverted? Because that would put this post at -2 at best in the old system, not knowing if any of the favoriters were "supervoters" at the time.

OOZ662 said:

Is every favorite still +1, or did that get reverted?

It got reverted, but AFAIK affected posts haven't had their scores readjusted after the switch back, so in some cases they're still abnormally high

fossilnix said:

It got reverted, but AFAIK affected posts haven't had their scores readjusted after the switch back, so in some cases they're still abnormally high

They seemed readjusted as well (noticed some posts lose a few dozens of score).

Drewko said:

To (re)flagger: This post has a +9 rating, so your work is kinda in wain because no matter what it will stay here. Please calm yourself and deal with the fact that community decided that this post will be not banned.

I have no idea where you're coming from here. Score has nothing at all to do with mod approval, from what I've seen. post #1929231, post #2205670, and post #1901422, to name a few examples, all had much higher scores than this before being flagged and deleted.

post #121855 succinctly sums up Danbooru's policy on favorites/score and how they apply to post approval. Also note the uploader on that post.